What Happens When You Report Workplace Harassment by Your Manager?

Independent HR investigator listening to an employee's workplace complaint

A workplace complaint can put an employee in a difficult position. It becomes even harder when the person being reported is the manager who has influence over your job, your working conditions and, potentially, your future with the organisation.

That was the situation Vivian Offor Chekwube faced when she reported her General Manager at African Foundries Limited for sexual harassment. What happened after her complaint eventually became the subject of a National Industrial Court judgment that raises important questions about how organisations handle workplace complaints.

When the person you need to report has power over your job

Chekwube joined African Foundries Limited in February 2020 as an Assistant Human Resources Manager, earning ₦175,000 monthly. Her immediate supervisor was the company’s General Manager, Pedro Emuata.

According to her evidence before the court, the problems started about two weeks after she resumed work. She alleged that Emuata asked her to date him and suggested that accepting his advances could benefit her professionally.

She said she rejected the advances because she did not want a personal relationship with a married man or to mix business with pleasure. According to her complaint, he then threatened to make her working life difficult and damage her position in the company.

This placed her in a difficult position. The person she said was making her uncomfortable was also the person she reported to at work.

She complained. Two days later, management wanted her to resign.

On 7 September 2020, Chekwube sent an email to the company’s management with the subject line Constant Harassment. She described what she said had been happening and formally brought the matter to the organisation’s attention.

On 9 September 2020, Pedro Emuata informed her that management wanted her to resign honourably. She refused to resign, and the situation eventually led to the termination of her employment.

The termination letter was dated 21 September 2020 and stated that her employment was terminated with effect from 9 September 2020. The letter accused her of providing false information about her previous employment history on her CV.

The company maintained that its decision was based on information obtained during reference checks, not her harassment complaint. It also argued that it had investigated her complaint.

However, the court would later examine whether the company could support these explanations with evidence.

What happened to the investigation?

This is where the case becomes particularly important for anyone who has ever had to report a manager or senior colleague.

The company said it had set up a panel to investigate Chekwube’s complaint. However, the court found that there was no investigation report to show what the panel had done or what conclusions it had reached.

A company witness also acknowledged that no investigation report had been produced. The court further considered the involvement of Emuata, who was the person accused of harassment, in the events surrounding the request for Chekwube’s resignation.

Think about what this means for an employee making a complaint. How confident can someone feel about an investigation when the person being reported is still involved in decisions affecting their employment?

An investigation must be more than a meeting or a discussion between managers. It should establish what happened, consider the available evidence and produce findings that can be properly explained and supported.

Without that process, an organisation may end up making decisions based on assumptions, personal influence or incomplete information.

The company accused her of falsifying her employment records

The company also argued that Chekwube had provided incorrect information about her previous employment at SPAR Nigeria and another organisation.

However, the court found that the company had not produced the reference-check reports needed to support its allegation. It also found that she had not been given a fair opportunity to respond to the accusations before they were used as the reason for ending her employment.

The company later raised other concerns about her alleged relationship with another employee and a decline in her productivity. The court found these allegations to be an afterthought, noting that there were no queries or warnings on record to support them.

This is an important point about how organisations handle employee misconduct. If an employer believes an employee has done something wrong, it must be able to support that position with evidence and follow a fair process.

A company cannot simply introduce different reasons whenever its original explanation becomes difficult to defend.

What the Nigerian court decided

On 1 June 2026, the National Industrial Court of Nigeria, sitting in Ibadan and presided over by Justice J.D. Peters, delivered judgment in Offor Vivian Chekwube v. African Foundries Limited, Suit No. NICN/IB/111/2020.

The court found that Chekwube had been denied a fair hearing before her employment was terminated. It also found that the company had failed to investigate her sexual harassment complaint and held the employer liable for the conduct of its General Manager.

The court considered the manager’s position within the organisation and the company’s failure to take appropriate action after receiving the complaint. It concluded that the company had condoned the harassment rather than properly addressing it.

The court declared the termination wrongful and illegal and ordered the company to pay the following:

AwardAmount
Damages for wrongful termination₦4,200,000
Punitive and exemplary damages₦4,000,000
Unpaid September 2020 salary₦175,000
Legal costs₦500,000
Total₦8,875,000

The court did not grant every amount Chekwube requested. For example, it did not award her the additional one month’s salary in lieu of notice.

The financial award was significant, but the wider message was about the responsibility organisations have when employees report misconduct by people in positions of authority.

What should you do when the person you need to report is your manager?

Reporting a manager can feel risky, particularly when that person has influence over your work, performance assessment or continued employment. However, knowing how to handle the situation can help you protect your position and make better decisions.

Here are some things worth considering.

1. Put your complaint in writing.

Where possible, report the issue through an appropriate formal channel. Explain what happened, when it happened and how it has affected your work.

2. Keep records of important communication.

Keep copies of relevant emails, messages, complaints and responses. Record dates and details of important incidents while they are still fresh in your memory.

3. Look at who is handling your complaint.

If the person you reported is involved in investigating the matter or making decisions about your employment, raise concerns about the independence of the process.

4. Pay attention to changes in how you are treated.

If you suddenly face threats, unusual disciplinary action, pressure to resign or other negative treatment after making a complaint, keep a record of what happens.

5. Seek appropriate advice.

Where the situation involves harassment, possible retaliation or termination, consider speaking with a qualified employment lawyer or an appropriate professional support organisation.

These steps do not guarantee a particular outcome, but they can help you understand your options and keep a clearer record of what has happened.

What should employers and managers take away from this case?

For employers, this judgment raises an important question about how much confidence employees can have in the organisation’s complaint process.

A reporting procedure means very little if employees cannot trust that complaints will be handled fairly. This becomes even more important when the person being reported is a senior manager.

Organisations should make sure that:

  • Complaints are handled by people who are independent of the individuals involved.
  • Managers accused of misconduct do not control the investigation.
  • Employees are given a fair opportunity to respond to allegations made against them.
  • Investigation findings and management decisions are properly documented.
  • Employees are not punished simply for raising genuine workplace concerns.
  • Disciplinary decisions are based on evidence rather than personal disagreements.

There is also a lesson for managers. Having authority over employees does not give anyone the right to use that position to demand personal favours, intimidate staff or make their working lives difficult.

Leadership comes with responsibility, and organisations must be prepared to address misconduct even when it involves people in senior positions.

Before you finish reading, consider your own workplace

Think about the last time someone in your organisation raised a serious complaint about a manager or senior colleague. Was the matter investigated independently, or did it quietly disappear after a few conversations?

The answer can tell you a lot about how your organisation handles responsibility and accountability. It can also help you recognise whether the complaint process is something employees can genuinely trust.

A workplace complaint should not become another problem for the employee

The case of Offor Vivian Chekwube v. African Foundries Limited reminds us that the way an organisation responds to misconduct can be just as important as the misconduct itself.

An employee who reports harassment should not have to wonder whether speaking up will put their job at risk. Equally, employers must understand that ignoring complaints or allowing senior managers to operate without accountability can have serious consequences.

A good workplace is not one where nobody ever raises a complaint. It is one where people can raise concerns and trust that those concerns will be taken seriously, investigated fairly and handled with care.

When an employee reports a problem, the organisation’s response says a great deal about the kind of workplace it really is.

Sources

National Industrial Court of Nigeria. (2026, June 1). Offor Vivian Chekwube v. African Foundries Limited (Suit No. NICN/IB/111/2020). https://nicnadr.gov.ng/nicnweb/details.php?id=11114&p=Offor+Vivian+Chekwube+-VS-+African+Foundaries+Limited

The Lawcrest. (n.d.). Review of Suit No. NICN/IB/111/2020 between Offor Vivian Chekwube v. African Foundries Limited. https://thelawcrest.com/review-of-suit-no-nicn-ib-111-2020-between-offor-vivian-chekwube-v-african-foundries-limited/

Tunde-Olowu, A., Ogbuagu, U., Ademola, A., & Oziwo, B. (2026, September 3). Nigeria: Trends and developments. In Employment 2026. Chambers and Partners. https://practiceguides.chambers.com/practice-guides/employment-2026/nigeria/trends-and-developments/


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment