

An assessment can be completed, marked and recorded, yet the organisation responsible for it might still be unable to prove what happened. That is where a routine record keeping problem can become a serious quality assurance issue, with consequences for learners, results and the trust people place in qualifications.
On 14 October 2026, Ofqual announced a £150,000 fine against the Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music (ABRSM) following failures involving assessment records, evidence retention and certification. The case raises an important question for anyone who manages training, examinations or quality assurance: what happens when an organisation needs evidence that it can no longer find?

What went wrong in the ABRSM case?
ABRSM provides music qualifications through face to face and digital assessments, and Ofqual has regulated it since 2010. According to Ofqual’s official announcement, the organisation experienced several incidents between 2024 and 2025 that affected assessment evidence, marking reviews, malpractice investigations and certificates.
One incident involved audio recordings from as many as 8,539 completed assessments that were not successfully retained. Examiners received messages indicating that their recordings had uploaded, but the files had not actually reached ABRSM’s system, and 20 learners who requested reviews of marking could not receive reviews based on all their original assessment evidence.
Another incident involved recordings and marking records for 16 learners that were accidentally deleted and could not be recovered. The loss delayed results and affected the learners’ ability to seek a review based on the original assessment records.
A separate malpractice investigation also exposed a problem with record retention. ABRSM could not investigate evidence relating to 231 learners fully because the relevant recordings were no longer available, while another incident involved 72,064 learners receiving certificates with incorrect qualification titles.
These were different problems, but they pointed to a common concern: the organisation could not always provide the records needed to support its assessment and certification processes. The formal enforcement notice published by Ofqual explains the findings in greater detail.
Why missing records can become a serious problem
Assessment evidence is what helps an organisation explain how a result was reached. Depending on the type of assessment, it could include marked scripts, observation notes, completed marking forms, recordings, learner identification checks or other records that support an assessment decision.
Without the necessary evidence, staff might be unable to answer a learner who questions a result or investigate a concern about how an assessment was conducted. Even when the original decision was reasonable, the organisation may struggle to demonstrate that it followed the right process.
This is why quality assurance involves more than checking whether forms have been completed or results entered into a system. The records must also be accurate, safe and available when someone needs them.
In examination administration and quality assurance, one important distinction is between completing a process and being able to show that the process worked. A file marked as uploaded, a completed checklist or a result entered into a database is useful only if the information behind it is reliable.
Three weaknesses worth checking
1. Trusting a message instead of checking the evidence
The ABRSM incident shows how easily a system message can create a false sense of security. Examiners believed their recordings had been stored because the application indicated that the uploads were complete, but the files were missing.
Training providers should check whether their systems confirm that files have actually arrived and can be retrieved. A successful message should not be the only proof that important evidence has been saved.
2. Having no reliable way to recover lost records
People make mistakes, devices fail and software does not always behave as expected. In the ABRSM case involving 16 learners, an administrative error and the loss of access to an examiner’s device contributed to the permanent loss of assessment records.
Providers should have suitable backups, clear access controls and a tested way to recover important files. They should also check whether staff can accidentally delete records and whether the system offers enough protection against such mistakes.
3. Keeping records for the wrong length of time
Keeping every record forever is not the answer because organisations must also protect personal information and follow appropriate disposal rules. However, deleting evidence too early can make it impossible to deal with an appeal or investigate suspected malpractice properly.
Providers need a clear record retention policy that reflects the requirements of their awarding bodies, regulators and applicable data protection rules. The policy should explain what needs to be kept, for how long, who is responsible and how staff should respond when an investigation or review is still open.
What quality assurance should look for
A quality assurance review should test whether the organisation can retrieve the evidence needed to support its assessment decisions. It should not stop at checking whether the expected documents appear to be present.
For example, a reviewer could select a sample of completed assessments and check whether each record is linked to the correct learner, whether the evidence can be opened and whether it supports the recorded outcome. The reviewer could also check whether backups work and whether staff know what to do when a file is missing.
Certification deserves similar attention because a correct assessment result can still be followed by an incorrect certificate. The ABRSM case shows why providers should check qualification titles and other important details before certificates are issued.
These checks should lead to action when weaknesses appear. If a problem is found, the organisation should identify its cause, assign responsibility for correcting it and check later that the correction has worked.
A practical step you can take this week
Choose five recently completed assessments and try to retrieve all the records needed to explain how each result was reached. Include the original evidence, marking records and any other documents required by your own assessment process.
Check whether the files are complete, correctly labelled and available to authorised staff. If one cannot be found, ask why it is missing and whether the same weakness could affect other learners.
This simple exercise can reveal problems that routine paperwork checks might miss. It also gives the quality assurance team something specific to improve instead of waiting for a complaint, appeal or external review to expose the weakness.
Final thoughts
The ABRSM case is a reminder that assessment records matter most when someone needs to question a decision, check a result or investigate a concern. By that point, discovering that important evidence is missing can leave the organisation with very few options.
For training providers and quality assurance professionals, the real test is whether their systems can support the decisions they make, even when something goes wrong. If a learner questioned an assessment result tomorrow, would your organisation have the evidence needed to explain what happened?
Sources
Information Commissioner’s Office. (n.d.). Principle (e): Storage limitation. https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/data-protection-principles/a-guide-to-the-data-protection-principles/storage-limitation/
International Organization for Standardization. (2025). ISO 21001:2025: Educational organizations: Management systems for educational organizations: Requirements with guidance for use. https://www.iso.org/standard/21001
Ofqual. (2026, September 11). Ofqual handbook: General conditions of recognition, Section G: Setting and delivering the assessment. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/ofqual-handbook/section-g-setting-and-delivering-the-assessment
Ofqual. (2026, October 14). Notice of monetary penalty on the Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music (ABRSM). GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/notice-of-monetary-penalty-and-costs-recovery-abrsm/notice-of-monetary-penalty-on-the-associated-board-of-the-royal-schools-of-music-abrsm

Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.