Why Some Coworkers Find It Hard to Trust Others at Work

Two coworkers building trust through conversation.

A new person joins the team. Most people are friendly, introduce themselves, and start working together without much difficulty. One coworker, however, keeps their distance. They answer questions politely but briefly. They rarely ask for help. They double check information before acting on it and seem uncomfortable sharing their thoughts too early.

It is easy to make assumptions. Some people might think they are unfriendly. Others may believe they are arrogant, secretive, or simply difficult to work with. The truth is often more complicated than that.

Trust does not begin at the same place for everyone. Some people naturally expect others to be trustworthy until they are given a reason not to. Others take the opposite approach. They need time, consistency, and repeated positive experiences before they feel safe enough to trust. This difference can affect almost every part of working life. It can influence teamwork, communication, decision making, and even how people build friendships at work. When we misunderstand this behaviour, small problems can quickly become bigger ones.

Understanding why some coworkers find it hard to trust others is not about making excuses for unhelpful behaviour. It is about seeing what may be happening beneath the surface so we can respond with greater awareness, clearer communication, and more realistic expectations. When you show your coworkers trust, you create a foundation where everyone can eventually feel safe enough to open up.

Trust Means Different Things to Different People

When people talk about trust, they often imagine it as something simple. Either you trust someone or you do not. Real life is rarely that straightforward.

For many people, trust grows little by little. It develops through everyday experiences. A promise is kept. Someone admits a mistake instead of hiding it. A colleague offers support without expecting something in return. Small moments like these slowly build confidence in another person.

For someone who finds trust difficult, those same moments may carry much more weight. They may need many positive experiences before they begin to relax. This does not always mean they are suspicious of everyone around them. It often means they have learned to be careful. That carefulness can sometimes be mistaken for coldness. The challenge is that we usually see behaviour, but we do not see the experiences that shaped it.

Trust Is Often Shaped Long Before Someone Joins Your Team

Every workplace has its own culture, but people do not arrive with a blank slate. They bring their previous experiences with them.

How Past Teams Influence Us

Someone who has worked in supportive teams may naturally expect openness and honesty. They may feel comfortable asking questions, sharing ideas, and relying on others. Someone else may have experienced broken promises, office politics, public criticism, or managers who blamed others whenever something went wrong. Those experiences can quietly influence how they approach every new workplace.

They may become slower to open up. They may wait before sharing ideas. They may keep conversations focused only on work. They may feel more comfortable relying on themselves than depending on other people. None of these behaviours automatically mean they dislike their colleagues. Often, they are simply trying to avoid repeating painful experiences. This is one reason first impressions can sometimes be misleading. What looks like distance may actually be caution.

Past Workplace Experiences Can Leave Lasting Effects

Many professionals have worked in environments where trust was damaged. Perhaps they shared an idea that someone else claimed as their own. Maybe they trusted a manager who later broke an important promise. Some have been blamed for mistakes they did not make. Others have discovered that private conversations quickly became office gossip.

The Hidden Rules We Create

Experiences like these do not disappear the moment someone starts a new job. Instead, they often become quiet lessons that shape future behaviour. A person may begin thinking that they will wait before they share their opinion. Or they may decide that they will keep important information to themselves until they know these people better.

These decisions are not always made consciously. Sometimes they become automatic ways of protecting themselves. This is one reason why two people can join the same organisation on the same day and respond very differently to the same team. One quickly feels at home. The other spends months carefully observing everyone around them.

Leadership Plays a Bigger Role Than Many People Realise

Managers have a powerful influence on whether people feel safe enough to trust. A leader who listens, communicates clearly, and treats people fairly often helps trust grow naturally.

On the other hand, leaders who regularly change their expectations, criticise people in front of others, play favourites, or avoid taking responsibility can create an atmosphere where trust becomes much harder. People working in those environments often become more cautious. They may stop speaking openly during meetings. They may avoid taking risks because they fear being blamed if something goes wrong. They may become reluctant to ask for help because they worry it will make them appear weak.

Over time, this cautious way of working can become a habit that follows them into future jobs, even when they are now surrounded by supportive colleagues. This is why trust cannot always be understood by looking only at the present workplace. Sometimes the present behaviour is connected to experiences from the past.

Some People Are Naturally More Careful

Not every trust issue comes from a bad experience. People naturally differ in how quickly they feel comfortable with others. Some enjoy meeting new people and quickly build working relationships. Others prefer to observe first. They like to understand how people communicate, how they solve problems, and whether their actions match their words. Neither approach is automatically right or wrong.

Being naturally careful does not mean someone lacks social skills. It also does not mean they expect the worst from everyone they meet. For many people, caution is simply how they make thoughtful decisions. Problems usually appear when others misunderstand that caution. A quiet colleague may be labelled as unfriendly. A careful colleague may be described as suspicious. Someone who asks detailed questions may be seen as lacking confidence when they are actually trying to avoid mistakes. These misunderstandings can create unnecessary tension before genuine working relationships have had a chance to develop.

Fear of Being Taken Advantage Of

Another reason some coworkers struggle to trust others is the fear of being taken advantage of. Many professionals have experienced situations where being helpful led to extra work without recognition. Some have watched others receive credit for ideas they contributed. Others have found themselves becoming the person everyone depends on while their own workload quietly became overwhelming.

After experiences like these, people often become more protective of their time, their knowledge, and even their willingness to help. To someone looking from the outside, this behaviour may seem selfish. In reality, it may simply be an attempt to create healthier boundaries after previous experiences left them feeling used. This does not mean every cautious coworker has been treated unfairly. It does remind us that behaviour often has a story behind it, even when we never hear that story.

How Low Trust Often Shows Up at Work

People do not usually walk into the office and say that they find it hard to trust people. Instead, trust often shows itself through everyday behaviour.

A coworker who struggles with trust may check their work several times before sending it. They may ask extra questions before agreeing to a plan. They might prefer emails instead of verbal conversations because written communication feels clearer and leaves less room for misunderstanding. You may also notice that they rarely share personal information. They keep conversations friendly but professional. They listen more than they speak, especially when they are new to a team.

Some people assume this means they are trying to stay separate from everyone else. That is not always the case. For many people, these behaviours are simply ways of feeling safe while they work out whether the people around them are reliable. As trust grows, many of these habits naturally begin to change.

Why We Often Misread Distrust

One of the biggest challenges in any workplace is that we tend to judge behaviour before we understand it. When someone is quiet, we may think they are unfriendly. When someone asks a lot of questions, we may think they are difficult. When someone prefers to work alone, we may assume they dislike teamwork.

Sometimes those assumptions are correct. Many times, they are not. The same behaviour can come from very different reasons. One person may avoid conversations because they feel anxious. Another may simply be focused on their work. Someone else may have learned from experience that speaking too freely has caused problems in the past. This is why understanding people requires curiosity rather than quick judgement. The more we rely on assumptions, the easier it becomes for misunderstandings to grow.

How Low Trust Affects the Whole Team

Trust is not only a personal experience. It influences how an entire team works together. When people trust one another, they are usually more willing to ask for help, admit mistakes, share ideas, and solve problems together. When trust is low, those same actions become harder. People may keep important information to themselves. They may hesitate before asking questions because they worry about looking incompetent. Small misunderstandings can take longer to resolve because people are less willing to speak openly. Over time, teamwork can become slower and more stressful.

At the same time, it is worth recognising that cautious people can also bring valuable strengths to a team. They often think carefully before making decisions. They may notice risks that others overlook. They usually take promises seriously and value consistency. The goal is not to change everyone’s personality. The goal is to create an environment where people feel safe enough to contribute their strengths without constantly feeling the need to protect themselves.

Building Trust Takes Time

Many people hope trust can be built with one conversation or one team building activity. Real trust usually grows much more quietly than that. It develops through small moments that happen again and again.

The Pillars of Everyday Trust

People notice whether you keep your word. They notice whether you treat everyone fairly. They notice whether you speak respectfully about people who are not in the room. They notice whether your actions match what you say. These everyday moments may seem ordinary, but together they create the foundation of trust. This is why consistency matters so much. Grand gestures are easy to remember, but consistent behaviour is what helps people feel safe over time.

What You Can Do If You Work With Someone Who Finds Trust Difficult

If you have a coworker who seems cautious, patient communication often works better than trying to force a close relationship. Keep your promises, even the small ones. Be clear about expectations. Avoid gossip, even when it feels harmless. Respect their boundaries instead of taking them personally.

Most importantly, allow the relationship to develop naturally. Some people build trust quickly. Others need more time. Trying to rush the process often has the opposite effect. People are more likely to trust someone who gives them space than someone who pressures them to open up.

What If You Are the One Who Finds Trust Difficult?

Reading this article may have made you recognise some of your own behaviour. If that is the case, remember that being careful is not automatically a weakness. Being thoughtful before trusting people can sometimes protect you from poor decisions.

The important question is whether your caution is helping you or limiting you. If every new colleague is treated as though they have already broken your trust, you may miss opportunities to build positive working relationships. Not everyone deserves immediate trust. At the same time, not everyone should be expected to earn back trust they have never broken. Finding a healthy balance can make work feel less stressful and help you build stronger professional connections over time.

A Moment to Reflect

People often carry invisible experiences into every workplace they join. Those experiences influence how they communicate, how they solve problems, and how quickly they feel comfortable with others.

Take a moment to think about your own working relationships. Is there someone you have labelled as difficult when they may simply be cautious? Or are there past experiences that still shape how easily you trust the people you work with today? Sometimes greater workplace intelligence begins with asking better questions rather than making quicker judgements.

Practical Next Step

Understanding why trust is difficult for some people is only the beginning. The real value comes from noticing how this understanding changes the way you respond at work.

Over the next week, choose one working relationship that feels distant or uncertain. Instead of trying to change it all at once, focus on one small action that builds consistency. It could be keeping a promise, communicating more clearly, listening without interrupting, or following through on something you said you would do. These small actions may not change the relationship overnight, but they create the kind of steady pattern that helps trust grow naturally.

The same idea applies if you are the one who struggles to trust others. Rather than expecting yourself to become completely open, look for one small opportunity to allow someone to earn your trust through their actions instead of assuming the outcome in advance. Small, consistent experiences often build stronger trust than big promises ever can.

Final Thoughts

Trust is one of the quiet foundations of every workplace. When it is present, people often work together without thinking much about it. When it is missing, even simple conversations can become more difficult.

Some coworkers find it hard to trust because of who they are. Others struggle because of what they have experienced. In many cases, it is a mixture of both. Understanding this does not mean accepting unhealthy behaviour or ignoring poor communication. It simply reminds us that behavior often has a deeper story behind it.

The more we learn to look beyond first impressions, the better we become at building workplaces where people feel respected, understood, and able to do their best work. Sometimes the strongest professional relationships do not begin with instant trust. They begin with patience, consistency, and a willingness to understand each other a little better every day.

Sources

Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development. (2024). Trust and psychological safety: An evidence review. https://www.cipd.org/en/knowledge/evidence-reviews/trust-psychological-safety/

Comcare. (2025). Building trust in your team. https://www.comcare.gov.au/safe-healthy-work/healthy-workplace/good-work-design/building-trust-in-your-team

National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. (2022). Mental wellbeing at work: Recommendations. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/NG212/chapter/recommendations

Office of the U.S. Surgeon General. (2022). The Surgeon General’s framework for workplace mental health and well-being. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. https://www.hhs.gov/surgeongeneral/reports-and-publications/workplace-well-being/index.html

State of California, California Department of Human Resources. (n.d.). Psychological safety guide. https://www.calhr.ca.gov/about-calhr/divisions-programs/deia-toolkit/templates-guides/psychological-safety-guide/


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment