

Constructive criticism sounds simple enough. Someone points out something you could improve, you listen, make the necessary change, and move on. In real working life, it is rarely that neat.
You may be a responsible professional who genuinely cares about doing good work. You may even tell colleagues or your manager that you appreciate honest feedback. Then someone actually points out a problem with your work, and you feel yourself becoming uncomfortable. Before you know it, you are explaining why you did what you did, giving them the background they do not know, or trying to make sure they understand that the situation was not entirely your fault.
The strange thing is that you may not even realise you are being defensive until the conversation is already going badly.
Most of us like to think we can take criticism. We want to believe that we are mature enough to hear when we have got something wrong. So it can be uncomfortable to notice ourselves doing the very thing we would criticise in someone else.
But defensiveness does not always come from arrogance. Sometimes it comes from the way we interpret what has been said.
When Criticism Feels Personal
Imagine your manager says, “Your report was useful, but some of the information was difficult to follow. Next time, make the main points clearer.”
On the surface, that is fairly straightforward feedback about a report.
But depending on how you are feeling, you may hear something completely different: They think I am not good at my job. I spent hours on that report. They have no idea what I was dealing with. Why am I always the one being corrected?
The manager commented on a piece of work. Your mind turned it into a statement about your professional ability.
That is often where defensiveness starts.
And the frustrating part is that your explanation may be perfectly valid. The deadline may have been unreasonable. You may have been working with incomplete information. Your manager may genuinely not have known about a problem that affected the work.
Those circumstances are worth explaining when they matter. They do not automatically make the feedback useless.
Two things can be true at the same time: there may have been circumstances your manager did not know about, and there may still be something you could have done better.
Being able to hold both ideas in your head is an important professional skill.
The Problem with Explaining Yourself Too Quickly
There is another reason to pay attention to this reaction. People at work are not only observing what you produce. They are also noticing how you respond when something you have produced is questioned.
If every criticism is followed by a long explanation, an argument, or a list of reasons why something was not your fault, people may eventually decide that giving you feedback is more trouble than it is worth.
They may stop telling you.
That can be more damaging than receiving criticism in the first place.
You might think everything is fine because nobody is complaining anymore. In reality, people may simply have learned that you do not respond well when your work is challenged.
This becomes increasingly important as your responsibilities grow. The more senior you become, the more you need people around you who will tell you when something is not working. Honest feedback becomes more valuable, not less.
You do not have to agree with everything people say. You do need to be able to hear it before deciding whether it is right.
Not Every Criticism Is Constructive
Of course, there is another side to this.
Some feedback is poorly delivered. Some people are unnecessarily harsh. Others make vague comments that leave you wondering what they actually want you to change. There are also situations where someone genuinely blames you for something that was outside your responsibility.
Being professional does not mean sitting quietly while someone treats you unfairly.
You can question what has been said. You can disagree or explain circumstances the other person does not know about. If the information is inaccurate, you can correct it. If someone is speaking to you disrespectfully, you can address that too.
The important question is not whether you should ever defend yourself. It is whether you are defending yourself before you have understood what you are being told.
That distinction matters.
If you react immediately, you may end up arguing with the person’s tone, intention or interpretation without dealing with the actual issue they raised. A short pause gives you a chance to separate the useful information from everything else.
Sometimes that is enough to turn a difficult conversation into a productive one.
What Your Defensiveness Might Be Telling You
There are times when the intensity of your reaction has very little to do with the actual comment.
You might be afraid of looking incompetent. You worked extremely hard, so hearing criticism can feel as though all that effort has been overlooked. And when being good at your job is a big part of how you see yourself, admitting a mistake can feel much bigger than it really is.
Past experiences can play a part too. If you have previously been criticised in a humiliating or unfair way, a similar conversation at work can put you on guard before you have even had time to consider what is being said.
Understanding this does not mean excusing the reaction. It simply gives you a better chance of managing it.
Instead of immediately saying, “But that wasn’t my fault,” you might ask, “Can you show me which part you think I should have handled differently?”
That question changes the conversation. You have moved from proving that you are a competent professional to finding out exactly what the other person is trying to tell you.
You Are Allowed To Take Your Time
There is no rule that says you must give a perfect response to criticism on the spot.
If you are caught off guard, it is perfectly reasonable to say, “Thanks for pointing that out. Let me think about it.”
You might ask for an example or say, “I understand what you’re saying. I’d like to look at what happened before I respond.”
That little bit of space can make a big difference.
Once the immediate emotion has settled, you can look at the situation more clearly. The feedback may have been fair, partly fair, or based on a misunderstanding of what actually happened. What matters is being able to separate the useful part from the part that does not fit the situation.
The point is that you are making that judgment after considering the feedback rather than while trying to protect yourself from it.
That puts you in a much stronger position.
Separate The Message From The Way It Was Delivered
One of the hardest things about workplace feedback is that the useful information can sometimes be buried inside an irritating delivery.
Your manager may have said it badly. A colleague may have sounded condescending. You may already have an unresolved issue with the person giving the feedback.
Those things are real, but they can easily become a distraction.
Try asking yourself, Even though I dislike the way this was said, is there anything useful in it?
Perhaps there is.
Maybe your reports really are difficult to follow. Perhaps you interrupt people too often in meetings. Maybe you leave colleagues waiting too long for updates. Your actual work may be good, but you may not communicate your progress clearly enough.
None of those discoveries is particularly pleasant. Still, knowing about a weakness gives you something to work on. A weakness that nobody is willing to tell you about can continue unnoticed for years.
How You Respond Shapes Your Professional Reputation
Your career is not built only on qualifications, achievements and good results. People also develop an impression of what it is like to work with you.
People pay attention to how you respond when someone raises a problem, how you handle a mistake without turning the conversation into an argument, and what you actually do with the feedback afterward.
Over time, those experiences shape how people see you as a colleague and as someone who can be trusted with greater responsibility.
This is why receiving feedback is more than a matter of workplace manners. It is part of career development.
You are constantly giving people information about how you work, including in moments when you would rather they were not paying attention.
DO NOT TURN FEEDBACK INTO SELF-BLAME
There is an opposite mistake worth avoiding.
Once you become determined to be good at receiving feedback, you can start believing that every criticism must be correct. You apologise when you have done nothing wrong. You question every decision you make. You become so worried about being corrected that you stop trusting your own judgment.
That is not growth either.
Good professionals do not accept every opinion about them as fact. They examine it.
Ask yourself what evidence supports the criticism. Is the problem something you genuinely contributed to? Is there information the other person does not have? Is this a pattern you have heard before, or is it a one-off complaint? Most importantly, is there something you can do differently next time?
Those questions allow you to learn without surrendering your judgment.
What To Do The Next Time Criticism Catches You Off Guard
The next time someone gives you difficult feedback, resist the urge to explain everything immediately.
First, make sure you understand what they mean. If necessary, ask for an example. Then take a moment to consider whether there is something in the criticism that you need to address.
If there is, acknowledge it and do something about it.
If you disagree, explain your position calmly and give the other person the information they may be missing.
And if the feedback exposes a genuine weakness, do not waste it.
Maybe you need to communicate earlier. Perhaps you need to check your work differently. Maybe you need to become clearer when speaking in meetings or stop repeating a behaviour colleagues have mentioned more than once.
You are not trying to become someone who never gets criticised. You are trying to become someone who can use criticism without allowing it to define you.
A Simple Exercise For This Week
Think about the last piece of criticism you received that really bothered you.
Instead of starting with, Was that person right?, ask yourself a different question:
What, if anything, was this feedback trying to show me?
Write down what comes to mind. Then separate what you believe was fair from what you believe was unfair.
You may discover that some of the criticism was useful even though you disliked the way it was delivered. You may also discover that part of it had more to do with the other person’s assumptions than with your actual performance.
Either way, you are looking at the situation with your own judgment rather than simply accepting or rejecting everything that was said.
Final Thought
Nobody enjoys discovering that their work could have been better, especially when they have put a lot of effort into it.
But discomfort is not always a sign that feedback should be rejected. Sometimes it is simply the first reaction you have before you have had time to consider what you are hearing.
The real professional skill is not agreeing with every criticism. It is being able to pause, listen carefully, examine what is true, reject what is unfair, and use what is genuinely helpful.
That is how criticism becomes useful rather than merely uncomfortable.
Sources
Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development. (2022, September 20). Performance feedback: An evidence review. CIPD: Performance feedback: An evidence review
University of New South Wales. (n.d.). Receiving feedback. UNSW: Receiving Feedback
Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service. (2022). Discipline and grievances at work: The Acas guide. Acas: Discipline and grievances at work
University of New South Wales. (n.d.). Constructive feedback. UNSW Staff Teaching Gateway. UNSW: Constructive Feedback

Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.